‘Voluntourism’ might be doing more damage than excellent

LONDON – Fast growth in the multi-billion dollar volunteer tourist market has prompted require tighter controls with concerns over exposing vulnerable environments to unskilled international labor and dodgy operators exploiting immigrants for earnings.

Voluntourism, which allows socially-conscious holiday-makers to pay countless dollars to work in poor communities across South America, Asia and Africa, has become a boom sector of the international travel industry.

Estimates of its size vary commonly. Nancy Gard McGehee, a specialist on sustainable tourism at Virginia Tech, says as numerous as 10 million volunteers a year are investing as much as $2 billion on the opportunity to take a trip with a function.

Carnival Corp., the world’s largest cruise operator, this month revealed a “social impact” cruise which allows travelers to take part in 3 days of volunteering, helping to cultivate cacao plants, constructing water filters and supplying English tutelage.

But with no industry regulator, advocates within the sector are concerned about the increasing varieties of companies included, without any system to hold them to make up the work that they do.

“One of the challenges facing people wanting to volunteer responsibly is that there is no independent quality standard, no recognized regulative body,” stated Simon Hare, development director of British charity Globalteer.

“There are small local attire along with big corporations who see volunteering as a way of driving earnings instead of an important part of a long term strategy for communities with genuine needs. At finest this can make volunteering a waste of time and at worst it can in fact be dangerous.”

Critics alert the absence of oversight implies volunteers can easily wind up in parts of the world without the abilities had to help, take away regional jobs, and form bonds with kids in requirement that are shortlived as they quickly carry on.

In the wake of the April 25 earthquake in Nepal, the United Nations kids’s agency, UNICEF, said it ended up being alarmed by reported cases of youngster trafficking, getting in touch with orphanages and volunteer companies to stop sending more willing workers.

“We would ask people to consider carefully the impact of volunteering or contributing funds to post-earthquake Nepali youngsters’s houses in Kathmandu. Without realizing it, such support may be indirectly damaging youngsters,” UNICEF stated.


UNICEF stated it had actually encountered the exact same problem in Cambodia, where there has been a rise in the variety of unregistered childcare institutions, kept afloat by the funds and steady influx of volunteer tourists from abroad.

“Numerous volunteers have absolutely no childcare abilities, and they’re being asked to carry out a duty of care for children who are vulnerable. In a developed country, that would not occur,” stated James Sutherland from Friends-International, a children’s charity based in Southeast Asia.

Australian academic Nichole Georgeou, co-author of “Looks excellent on your CV: the sociology of voluntourism recruitment in college”, said part of the issue was that the industry is customer driven rather than driven by the needs of the local neighborhoods included.

“There’s this concept that is built-in in voluntourism that we in the West have the understanding and the abilities to make a difference, we have a right to make a difference,” stated Georgeou from the Australian Catholic University.

“It doesn’t even matter if we’re unskilled, it’s just the good will that matters since we’re somehow bonding anyway.”

A recent research study by Britain’s Leeds Metropolitan University, published in the Journal of Sustainable Tourism, alerted students thinking about a project for a gap year or summer season break that the most costly trips were found to be the “least responsible”.

Authors Victoria Smith and Xavier Font said volunteer tourism companies needed to take more obligation.

“These companies have a responsibility to ensure their programs have positive and not unfavorable impacts and ought to provide financial openness,” stated their report.

“This implies proper requirements evaluations, appropriately recruited, matched and experienced volunteers dealing with residents, with clear objectives, sustainable program management, reporting and lasting effect and respect.”

Some returning volunteers have expressed their concerns about the unfavorable effect they might have had.

“The kids [in the orphanage] were so made use of to seeing volunteers that they were hardly paying attention to us,” said Carla Salber, who volunteered in Cambodia with Projects Abroad, one of the biggest voluntourism business. “We felt betrayed.”

Voluntourism advocates contest the claim that the market is doing more harm than good, citing many schools and houses that would not have been built without voluntourists and their funding.

“The concept that individuals shouldn’t come at all in case they shock a youngster who had the most awful [experience] in their life already is actually bordering on the ridiculous. All our volunteers want to do is assist,” said Peter Slowe, founder and director of voluntourism supplier Jobs Abroad.

Globalteer’s Hare said it was an error to lump together good volunteering with bad volunteering and call it all ‘voluntourism’.

“This is a shame since there are companies running actually impactful volunteer programs,” he informed the Thomson Reuters Foundation. Regulation of the industry was the next step.

“For volunteering to be reliable, more focus needs to be on making certain it is done correctly,” he stated.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *